Temple: The Unluckiest School in the history of sports

Yankee Stadium’s tribute to Lewis Katz, Temple great and part owner of the YES Network.

On the precipice of winning a national title in basketball, John Chaney recruited two of the top big men in the nation only a decade apart.

Robert Liburd, the 7-foot-2 High School Player of the Year in New York City, and Marvin Webster Jr., the 6-11 power forward and stretch five and son of the great Marvin Webster, were two of many McDonald’s All-Americans (others included Kevin Lyde, Donald Hodge and Mark Macon) who committed to Chaney.

Liburd and Webster tragically dropped dead before they ever got on the court for the Owls.

That robbed John Chaney of his national championship IMHO.

Fran Dunphy’s best recruit was Trey Lowe out of Trenton, N.J. and he never made an impact because of a car accident. Lowe was a top 150 high school talent who maybe might have worked his way into being a top 15 college talent.

That robbed Dunphy of his deep NCAA tournament run.

With some of that knowledge behind me, I got to thinking Temple sports was cursed but it really hit me the day Temple was the only football team to get kicked out of a major conference in 2002 when the Big East pulled the plug.

Fortunately, Temple made its own luck when Bill Bradshaw hired Al Golden (not a buddy) and Golden beat that conference’s Fiesta Bowl rep, UConn, 30-10, in 2010.

More luck was made by a Golden disciple, Matt Rhule, who beat Penn State, 27-10, in 2015 and got the Owls on night prime time TV after the program was celebrated all day on the major networks as Philadelphia turned out big time for ESPN College Football Game Day.

Unfortunately, Temple’s biggest athletic booster, Lewis Katz, never got to see that day because he died in a plane crash on May 31, 2014.

He did, though, live long enough to see his beloved Owls accepted back into a major conference (also the Big East).

No prouder New Yorker than Lewis Katz to see this big sign in Times Square welcoming the Owls back to the Big East.

He did not live long enough, though, to see his AD hire a guy to be head coach who left 18 days later for Miami. That might have killed him.

If that didn’t, surely what happened 18 days later–Pat Kraft hiring an Indiana buddy off a Manny Diaz rebound–would have.

Or maybe if Katz was here all of that would not have happened.

More bad luck.

If luck is the residue of design, Temple owns that, too.

Temple never learned from the bad Karma of the buddy system of hiring and allowed another buddy, Arthur Johnson, to hire another buddy, Stan Drayton.

Maybe that wouldn’t have happened if Katz was here but we will never know.

Now, in an NIL/Transfer Portal Era where the Lew Katz’s of the world are buying the best players, Temple’s luck might have ran out.

Temple needs a new Lew Katz more than ever and, sadly, there are no Lew Katz’s around or no one wants to step into that void. Those of us who do want to step in do not have the funds to own an entire TV network, as Katz once did.

So maybe Temple is the unluckiest school in the history of sports. Given what’s happened, I challenge anyone to find an unluckier school.

My fervent hope is that Temple’s luck has not run out. It is also my biggest fear.

Friday: Poor Survivors

Monday: State of the Union

6 thoughts on “Temple: The Unluckiest School in the history of sports

  1. Yes, Temple some very bad luck in it’s athletic history. But far too much of it’s bad “luck” success in football has been because of poor HC hires and now ridiculous contracts like we’re experiencing with Drayton.

    • Yes, a lot of Temple’s troubles can be traced to an AD from Texas who hired an RB coach from Texas and that RB coach from Texas hired a DC who he knew from Texas State and that Texas State guy hired a bunch of assistants from Texas State who were 2-10 the last time they were all together.

    • Had a hearty laugh (followed by a cry) to read the transcript of Drayton’s talk with Kevin Copp about the No. 1 thing he’s concerned about is the battle for QB between a guy who has 4 career TD passes vs. 6 interceptions against a guy who got beat 55-0 by SMU last year. Never even mentioned that a quarterback who beat that same SMU team the prior year (and was named MVP of the New Mexico Bowl) is still in the portal looking for a team. These Temple coaches are so unaware of the portal it is scary.

      • Unaware or unbelievably stubborn – I still say something is going on behind the scenes for this kind of stuff to be happening and being allowed to happen. smh.

      • You might be onto something there. If I’m rolling the dice on my career as a HC on a guy with four TD passes vs. six INTs and an unproven JUCO, I might care a lot more about my future as an assistant than a HC.

Leave a comment