Gone: Hard to believe, Harry (Donahue)

At the 4:15 time stamp, Harry Donahue makes the greatest radio call in Temple history.

One day, two sucker punches to the solar plexus.

Two giants in Philadelphia radio, one giant of Temple sports radio.

First, heard that WMMR music radio legend Pierre Robert passed away listening while listening to the radio around 2:43 p.m. today.

Then, 15 minutes later, flipped open the phone and saw that my former colleague at The Philadelphia Inquirer, Mike Jensen, posted that Harry Donahue passed away.

Both were hard to believe, especially Harry.

Harry was particularly fond of the Cherry helmets with both White and Cherry uniforms.

Robert, because I just listened to a block of The Grateful Dead that an erstwhile healthy Robert played on Tuesday at noon. Grateful Dead. Maybe it was a premonition.

“I’m going to play a block of the Dead,” is the exact way Robert said it.

One day before he died.

Wow.

He sounded good but less than 24 hours later was found dead in his home. Just goes to show you never really know how long you have and to treat every day like a blessing.

Also didn’t know Harry was sick, but haven’t seen him in a couple of years but didn’t hear that he had any health issues.

Harry Donahue was the favorite of a generation of Temple fans, both football and basketball, because of his longevity. He wasn’t the best in my mind but that’s no knock on Harry because Wayne Hardin brought over the great Ron Menchine, the longtime Navy play-by-play guy, to do Temple football when Hardin got the Owls’ job.

Yet Harry was the ONLY one a generation of Temple fans knew because he did both basketball and football for 30 years.

I will say this. Donahue had the greatest single call of a Temple sporting event I’ve ever heard and that was the upset of No. 10 Virginia Tech in Blacksburg, Va. in 1998.

In those days, the Temple road games weren’t on television and the only way you could keep up with them was a transistor radio. I was jogging up East River Drive (I still refuse to call it Kelly Drive) wearing my Temple football jersey and holding the transistor in one hand.

When they won and Harry made that call (4:15 timestamp, top video), I did a 37-inch vertical leap and pumped both my fists. Coming at me the other way was another guy wearing Temple swag.

“Did Temple win?” he asked.

“28-24, they won,” I said.

“I’m Raheem Brock’s father,” he said.

“Are you Zach Dixon?”

“No, I’m his stepfather. Great news.”

Great news delivered by Harry on that day, sad news about Harry on this one.

Hard to believe indeed.

Friday: East Carolina Preview

Temple radio: A Long History Comes to An End

As a journalism major at Temple back in the late 1970s, they made us take a course on public relations even knowing many of us would be in the traditional media.

The thought process behind that was we needed to know how the other side wrote.

Really, the whole process of PR a lot of times is polishing a turd and that’s exactly what the Temple PR team did on Thursday.

Dave Sims called the 1990 season for Temple football, including a 23-18 win at Wisconsin over Barry Alvarez’s team.

Can’t take credit for that description but saw it on the Temple basketball facebook site and almost spit out my coffee laughing.

“That release was like polishing a turd,” one of the guys said.

No shit.

The PR release in question was that Temple was announcing an “exciting” new format for broadcasting its major sports games and nowhere in that release did the university include terrestrial radio in its plan.

What does that mean?

A tradition that goes back to at least 1937–and probably even further back–comes to an end with the Aug. 30th opener at Oklahoma.

You will be able to hear Temple radio on a streaming basis but for the first time in history you won’t be able to get in your car and turn the dial to a Temple football game. You won’t be able to carry a transistor radio to hear a Temple football game.

Don’t know if Temple is the only school that doesn’t broadcast its games on a regular radio station, but pretty sure it is probably one of the very few.

And that’s pretty sad because my first job in journalism after Temple was being the sports editor of an afternoon daily in Norwich, N.Y. and the Temple football radio network back then included 10 stations, the farthest north of which was in Binghamton. I could even hear Temple football on the radio in the Southern Tier of New York state.

The “Temple football radio network” went from double-digit number of stations in the 1970s to one in the 1990s and after.

Ron Menchine: The greatest Temple football play-by-play guy ever.

That’s sad because many of my great Temple football moments are radio-related.

When I was an underclassman at Temple, the games were broadcast both on WRTI-FM and WCAU (1210 AM).

Students like Howie Herman did the play-by-play and Jim Kelsh did the color on WRTI. On the AM dial that reached 40 of the 48 states on a cloudless night, the great Ron Menchine did the play-by-play and Heisman Trophy winner Joe Belino did the color.

While the two students who were my friends at Temple did a great job, Menchine and Belino brought a big-time aspect to the Temple broadcasts.

Former Navy coach Wayne Hardin brought both announcers over from Navy radio.

For many of the road games, I doubled as both the Temple News correspondent and the statistician and spotter for Ron and Joe. The two could not have been nicer to a 17-year-old kid and Belino probably was the humblest Heisman Trophy winner I ever met.

Menchine had a big-time voice and tabbed former Owl fullback Henry Hynoski, a 1,000-yard rusher, as “Dynamo Hyno.”

Hynoski had the kind of running style where he would burst through the line, knock over a linebacker, break a tackle of a safety before he was caught from behind by a corner.

Menchine: “Dynamo Hyno looks like Bronco Nagurski out there.”

As a 17-year-old kid, I had no idea who Bronco Nagurski was but since Google didn’t exist back then, I went into the Paley Library the next Monday and looked him up.

Pretty high praise by Ron.

Temple had a few radio announcers after that who didn’t quite measure up.

Steve Fredericks was one.

He was arrested for doing drugs at Kensington and Allegheny and lost his career not only as a play-by-play guy but as a sports talk show host.

Before Menchine and Fredericks, Pro Football Hall of Famer Merrill Reese did the Temple football games of head coach George Makris. I assume he called at least one touchdown by a fullback who wasn’t as good as “Dynamo Hyno” but became more famous.

A guy named Bill Cosby.

Dave Sims was the play-by-play guy for the 7-4 1990 season and his call of the 23-18 win at Wisconsin that year was a masterpiece. Now Dave calls the NFL on Westwood One and is the Seattle Mariners’ baseball play-by-play guy.

For most of the years after Menchine, the play-by-play guy was Harry Donahue. He became famous for his call of the final play in Temple’s 28-24 upset win at No. 10 Virginia Tech.

Since my headphones weren’t working that day, I carried the radio on my jog up East River Drive (now Kelly Drive) listening to the Temple game and wearing my Temple game jersey. When they won, I did a 37-inch vertical leap and pumped my fist. Running the other way, a jogger asked me what the Temple score was.

“28-24, they won,” I said.

“I’m Raheem Brock’s father,” he said.

“Are you Zach Dixon?”

“No, I’m his stepfather. Great news.”

Most of the time, though, I remember Donahue’s calls as going something like this:

“Mike McCann goes back to pass and it’s a touchdown! No, check that, it’s dropped.”

(Needless to say, when Temple moved to the MAC I could see all the road games on my laptop and stopped listening to the radio.)

Temple had another announcer named Don Henderson who pronounced Sid Morse’s name as “Sid Morris” for all four years of his Temple career.

I always thought Sid deserved better.

By Saam came to Philadelphia to do Temple football in 1937. He ended up being the most iconic Phillies play-by-play guy before Harry Kalas.

Temple football broadcasts can be traced way back to 1937 when the play-by-play guy was Ft. Worth Texas native By Saam, who became voice of the Phillies for 30 years.

Nobody knows if the famous Saam flubs existed back then but here were a couple of his with the Phillies:

Saam, who attended high school with golf legend Ben Hogan and college with Sammy Baugh, once created a beheading on air.

“Alex Johnson is going back. He’s going back, back. His head hits the wall. He reaches down, picks it up, and throws it into second base.”

Saam once opened a game by saying, “Hello, Byrum Saam, this is everybody speaking.” (This goof has also been credited to other announcers, including Lindsey Nelson and Phil Rizzuto.) Prior to Game 5 of the 1959 World Series, when Mel Allen introduced the NBC Radio audience to “amiable, affable, able Byrum Saam”, a distracted Saam unthinkingly replied, “Right you are, Mel Allen.” 

Would have loved to hear how By called some Temple games in the 1930s. Or would have loved to hear some tapes of the Sugar Bowl team on the radio in 1934.

Now the capable duo of Kevin Copp and Paul Palmer are doing the games but you won’t be able to get in your car to hear the post-game show anymore and I’m too stubborn to do the bluetooth thing. I’m guessing I’m not the only one.

For me, it’s been a great 50 years of Temple radio that will finally come to an end and there is no PR team alive that can polish that turd.

Monday: Translations

Cheers for Boo

booharry

Paul and Harry are already in the booth at ND stadium doing a sound check. Just kidding, photoshop courtesy of Matt Morgis.

When is being second better than being first?
When you are talking about the Heisman Trophy vs. the Maxwell Award, that is.
The Maxwell has always been a poor man’s Heisman, but Temple has one Maxwell Award-winner, Steve Joachim (1974). That was a remarkable achievement, but it wasn’t the Heisman (it went to Archie Griffin that year). Joachim has been the Owls’ color analyst alongside Harry Donahue for the past 17 years and did a good job.

Paul Palmer politely applauds for Vinny Testaverde. (We all know who SHOULD have won.)

Paul Palmer politely applauds for Vinny Testaverde. (We all know who SHOULD have won. Even Testaverde and Bosworth were wearing Temple Cherry ties that day.)

The Heisman, though, is a whole different animal. When Paul Palmer sat down with eventual winner Vinny Testaverde (Miami), third-place finisher Jim Harbaugh Jr. (Michigan) and fourth-place finisher Brian Bosworth (Oklahoma), he put Temple in the national spotlight that the Maxwell could not have provided.


Temple Radio Fun Fact:
Owls have had a Heisman winner
(Joe Bellino), a Heisman runner up
(Paul Palmer) and a Maxwell Award
winner (Steve Joachim) as radio
color guys

I think Palmer, the Heisman Trophy runner up (1986), will do a great job as Harry Donahue’s new analyst and I’m happy to see him on the radio team this season, beginning Saturday (3:30 p.m., 97.5 The Fanatic).
How do I know that?
Paul, or Boo-Boo as he’s called by his friends (now mostly shortened to Boo), had a gig as a sideline reporter for the Owls. In those days, I brought a transistor radio to the games (to hear mostly about the injuries) and HAD to listen to the radio for the road games because the Owls were rarely on TV.

Paul with Bob Hope, who lived to 100 accepting his first-team All-American Award on live NBC TV.

Paul, holding the greatest helmet in college football history, with Bob Hope, accepting his first-team All-American Award on live NBC TV.

In a game at the Vet against Virginia Tech, the Owls were having trouble kicking extra points and field goals. They already had missed two field goals and an extra point, but if Virginia Tech proved one thing that day it was they could not stop Big East Offensive Player of the Year Walter Washington, the Temple quarterback. On several plays, Washington could be seen literally dragging two or three Hokies on his back for 10 or so extra yards. Washington was 6-4, 250 and an Abrams’ Tank out there. VT players were infantrymen by comparison.  He could not be stopped on any potential two-point conversion. Temple knew it and VT knew it.
Washington scored in overtime. An extra point would have tied the game. A two-point conversion would have won it. Normally, the “football play” would have been to kick the extra point, but this was no normal day. The Owls didn’t have a kicker, but they had a guy VT couldn’t stop. Harry threw it down to Paul, who suggested, very strongly, that the Owls give the ball to Washington to end the game here.
“Somebody’s got to grow a pair,” Paul said, referring to Bobby Wallace.
Paul said what every Temple fan was thinking and he suggested exactly what Wallace should have done.
Wallace didn’t grow a pair, went for the tie, and missed the extra point.
My admiration for Paul, already high, went through the roof that day.
Temple fans will love listening to him on the radio this fall.
I’m bringing the transistor along again.

Tomorrow: The Helmet Surprise

Thanks to the NCAA suspending Johnny Manziel, his bowl game against Temple is still in play ...

Thanks to the NCAA suspending Johnny Manziel for only one half of the first game, his bowl game against Temple is still in play …