Fizzy’s Corner: Could’ve, Would’ve, Should’ve


Editor’s Note: Dave “Fizzy” Weinraub (pictured), a former Temple player and later a coach, educator, and writer, provides his expert perspective in this space every week.

By Dave “Fizzy” Weinraub

Outlined against a blue-gray October sky, the Four Horsemen of Temple University rode again. In dramatic lore they are known as Famine, Pestilence, Destruction and Death. These are only aliases. Their real names are Armstead, Wright, Gardner, and Russo. They formed the crest of the Broad Street cyclone before which another fighting  Navy football team was swept over the precipice as spectators peered down on the bewildering panorama spread on the green plain below.


Wait, there’s something wrong.  The master horseman wasn’t there.  Armstead was on the sideline watching the drama unfold as he was too injured to play.  Why?  Well because Coach Collins allowed him to continue to play in a blowout the week before, even after an injury in the fourth quarter.  To make matters worse, the coach refuses to address either the injury or his mistake. Yesterday when asked, he shrugged and said, “We’ll keep getting better.”

It’s the measure of a man who admits his mistakes and apologizes.  Coach Collins needs to come out front.

Now, on to the game with Navy.  For those who think I’m beating a dead horse, let’s look at the first two offensive series yesterday.  Do you think we really wouldn’t have scored with a first and goal on the half-yard line if Ryquell was playing?  Do you think we’d have fumbled the ball right back again on the second series if the master horseman was riding?  That’s a possible fourteen points and could have put the game away, right away.  As we get ready to play three top 25 teams, we need our best running back to be healthy.

To borrow a word from Grantland Rice above, there were some bewildering offensive play calls as usual.  Play fakes on third and long, two up-the-guts after a first down incompletion (borrowed from Andy Reid), a punt on fourth and one from on the Navy side of the field, throwing from an empty backfield on second and short, and the fade that was intercepted in the end-zone with two minutes to play.

On the other hand, the draw play for a touchdown was a terrific call, and we continue to see Russo roll out and run a few keepers.  I’d really like to see him run some RPO’s.

It’s very tough to evaluate the defense when it’s playing against the triple option, as there are many theories out there.  Wayne Hardin once told me his theory was to over-shift the defensive line to the strong side. Some coaches will assign one linebacker to tackle the fullback, one to hit the QB, and one for the pitch.  As Navy doesn’t throw well, man-to-man pass coverage should suffice.  I’m thankful we got ahead just in time to force them to do that.

A win is a win.  However, in Woulda, Coulda, Shoulda Land, we are now 6 – 1.

Tomorrow: 5 Takeaways From the Game

Thursday: A Special Homecoming

Saturday: How good is Vegas?

Sunday: Game Analysis


9 thoughts on “Fizzy’s Corner: Could’ve, Would’ve, Should’ve

  1. How does this team get to six wins?

    Cincy – L
    UCF – L
    Houston – L
    USF – W
    UCONN – W

    The Cincy coach is really good. He has done a tremendous job of recruiting, developing, and coaching on game day. Has completely out-coached Collins in all three areas this year and last.

    UCF is a top 5 team.

    TUFB never wins in Houston. The game will be over before kick-off, that atmosphere rocks, and rattles opponents.

    USF doesn’t like to play in Philly.

    UCONN is bad.

    This team will be a 10 win team next year if the OC leaves before January. Another 6-6 if he stays.

    • For reasons I cannot decipher TU is favored by 3 1/2 against Cinncy.

      • Despite Cincy being 6-0, they’ve played a weak schedule. UCLA , UConn, Tulane, Ohio University, Alabama A & M, & Miami (OH).

        I think they’re giving Temple the pts , because it’s a home conference game.

    • You seriously think will get 10 wins next year,with this schedule ? I see Temple going 6-6 next year.

      08/31 – Bucknell
      09/14 – Maryland
      09/21 – at Buffalo
      09/28 – Georgia Tech
      TBA – Memphis
      TBA – Tulane
      TBA – UCF
      TBA – UConn
      TBA – at Cincinnati
      TBA – at East Carolina
      TBA – at SMU
      TBA – at USF

  2. Maybe the odds makers see the talent of a good Temple team not the to many to name inconsistencies of a play calling coach!!!!!!!

    • Don’t doubt Vegas; navy line opened at 4.5 moved to 5.5 and settled on 7…uncanny

      • Mike, I learned a long time ago, the hard way, that lines makers are some of the most astute people on the planet and that over the long haul, they cannot be beaten. You have to win eleven out of 21 games just to break even with the vig, which is very hard to do consistently. There are really are no best bets unless you have inside information, which was the reason, allegedly, for the success of the person the Ace Rothstein character is based on in the movie Casino. That’s why I stopped betting sports 35 years ago. Why lines makers aren’t running things is a mystery because one would think that their analysis would apply to a whole bunch of things. .

  3. Fizzy reminds me of a “get off my lawn” old guy. Still, he makes some good points, as do you, and gives a player’s perspective as to why they might be questioning Patenaude. Players separated by 60 or so years are still Temple players.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s