Author Archives: Mike Gibson

01.05.25
by

When your best offer is Tarleton State

One word of caution for Temple players looking to jump into the transfer portal.

Don’t.

By all indications, most especially the eye test, Terrez Worthy was a pretty good player for Temple football this past fall.

Maybe the best from a pure production standpoint.

This is the Tarleton State practice facility (note that tiny building is where the locker room and weight room is).

But he’s getting pretty bad advice from who knows where?

That’s because he’s been in the portal for a few weeks now and the best (only?) offer he has is from Tarleton State.

We had to look up where Tarleton State was and it is in Stephenville, Texas. Its practice facility is a couple of storage lockers and a grass field, while Temple has a $17 million practice facility at 10th and Diamond.

On the field, Tarleton State doesn’t have a TV contract and plays pretty obscure opponents in Drake, West Georgia, Eastern Kentucky, Utah Tech (not regular Utah or Temple opponent Utah State) and Austin Peay. (Worthy also has a scheduled visit to UTEP but that is also a worse program than Temple by any measurement.)

Can’t imagine there’s a whole lot of NIL money available at a school that can barely afford pads and jerseys but there are always players at Temple and pretty much every G5 school who believe the grass is greener on the other side of the 10th and Diamond fence.

It almost never is.

According to a fan post on OwlsDaily.com, these players are among the many who have current Temple offers.

If Worthy’s tale should be anything, it should be a cautionary one. He would be welcome back to Temple if he chose to return and would have the benefit of playing in an NFL stadium in a big-time league with a big-time TV contract and a Hall of Fame head coach.

The point here is that, after three-straight 3-9 seasons, not a whole lot of suitors are going to come after Temple players so those who have scholarships would be wise to keep them and not lose them.

There are plenty of good players in the portal who would love to have a Temple scholarship and a number of them have reached out to new head coach K.C. Keeler first.

The great majority of players who have entered the transfer portal over the last three years–not just at Temple–have not only become homeless but lost a valuable scholarship at a school whose degree unlocks a lot of doors to a promising future.

Cooper Blomstrom, one of the top-rated edge rushers, just posted he has a Temple offer.

Plus, they would be on TV in the fourth-largest market in the nation with a lot more eyeballs on them than they would at a FCS school or a lower-tier FBS one. Many of those eyeballs are NFL scouts.

Got to feel for Worthy in the sense that the past Temple staff didn’t recognize his talent until midway through the season. To have a back like E.J. Wilson starting ahead of him in the first few games was borderline criminal.

That’s also the same kind of talent evaluation that put Forrest Brock as the starting QB ahead of a clear better choice, Evan Simon.

With K.C. Keeler, those days are over and any player lucky enough to have a Temple scholarship would be wise to keep it.

01.02.25
by

K.C. Keeler: Trust, but verify

K.C. Keeler’s New Year’s Eve message to Temple fans.

If you had to create a perfect Temple football coach in a petri dish, you would be hard pressed getting the DNA to replicate a K.C. Keeler.

Born North of Philadelphia, had success both East and South of Philadelphia with other teams, intimately familiar with the team in the middle who gave him his only loss in the 1979 season.

Hell, he wanted to go to Temple but head coach Wayne Hardin ran out of scholarships.

Not hard to trust K.C. Keeler as my football coach for the next few years.

That said, as Ronald Reagan might say of the Soviet Union when it made a nuclear weapons sweetheart deal with the U.S., “trust but verify.”

K.C. Keeler said his goal was to be in a bowl game immediately. If so, he needs to upgrade the roster via the transfer portal with about 20 solid FBS/FCS players right now.

For a guy who got a new job in December, he’s been pretty slow to make major moves on the coaching offensive side of the football or the transfer portal.

There are a couple of clues about the verify part.

Keeler hasn’t announced a new offensive coordinator and that might be because one of the leading candidates, a running backs’ coach from Penn State, is currently otherwise occupied. If so, I’m more than willing to wait.

The transfer portal is another story.

Temple has been slow to pull the trigger. Maybe too slow.

Kinda hoping that Al Golden’s first national title was with Temple but, that being impossible, I am literally betting on him to take it all as ND’s DC and I made that bet 14 days ago.

Watching Notre Dame win its quarterfinal game on Thursday night against Georgia, 23-10, it was abundantly clear they did it on the backs of two transfer portal acquisitions: 1) Duke’s Riley Leonard and 2) Marshall’s Jayden Harrison.

Temple fans are all too familiar with Leonard, who led Duke to a 30-0 win over Temple in Stan Drayton’s first game.

Notre Dame went out and got a big-time P4 quarterback in Leonard.

Temple can’t do that but certainly a big-time FCS quarterback is within reach. In my humble opinion, I can ride or die with Evan Simon who has shown he is Temple tough. I can’t depend on either Forrest Brock or Tyler Douglas to be a capable AAC backup. Keeler has to show me he can either convince the Sam Houston starting quarterback to come here to compete for the job with Simon or get me a star-level FCS quarterback to do the same.

I love Evan Simon as my quarterback and I’m sure once Keeler sees him throw a few balls in practice he will feel the same way. The film is the film. All K.C. has to do is to watch the entire Utah State game. If Simon played against UConn, the Owls win by at least two touchdowns. I will never change my mind about that. Simon has been quoted as saying he loves Temple.

(For the record, Simon wins the job in my mind.)

Harrison was the No. 1 kickoff returner in the country for Marshall last year and ended up at ND as a portal transfer. His return the house to open the second half was maybe the key play in a national quarterfinal game. Temple hasn’t had a good kickoff returner since Isaiah Wright was named AAC’s Special Teams’ Player of the Year in 2018.

Does Keeler have to get me the No. 1 FBS kickoff returner in the country?

Hell no.

I’ll take the top FCS kickoff returner. I’ll take the top Division II kickoff returner.

Just don’t give me another JUCO like Stan Drayton has done.

The trust the level with a guy who has done it at Rowan, Delaware and Sam Houston State is off the charts.

The verify level will come with what we see in the next couple of weeks.

Hoping it’s a nuclear-type jawn like Reagan had with Gorbachev but as always in this space we will be honest with what we see.

12.30.24
by

What Temple can take from Navy’s win

If Temple can keep a lot of players like Khalil Poteat, it should be OK next season.

About a year and a month ago, Temple got a terrific game from a quarterback and a linebacker and earned a 32-18 win over Navy.

A couple of days ago Navy completed a 10-win season with a win over an Oklahoma team that opened this season by beating Temple, 51-3.

The AAC’s image improved this bowl season. Now it’s time for Temple to contribute to that profile.

If anything, the juxtaposition shows how much fortunes can change in one year.

That’s because the transfer portal system both giveth and taketh away. The schools who decide to build their rosters with high school players will be left behind by the other schools who judiciously scour the portal to upgrade their rosters with 20 or so new players who can compete for starting spots.

So far, Temple head coach K.C. Keeler has talked about building a team through high school players and, as the lady on the video said, “ain’t nobody got time for that.”

Me when I heard K.C. wants to build his roster with high school players.

For now, let’s hope that is all that it is–talk.

However, if Keeler adds a couple of key players from, say, Sam Houston, a few all-star type players from FCS ranks and as many disaffected really good players from P4 schools who can’t get on the field there that’s the formula to do what Navy did–go from three wins (and dominated by a three-win team)–to, if not 10, then eight or nine wins.

Ironically, Navy got better not from an influx of new players but from being able to retain its roster. Temple can do the same but still needs to keep the good players like quarterback Evan Simon and a few others.

On the flip side, the Owls need to upgrade their offensive line with solid players from the portal (be it FCS, Sam Houston or P4) so Simon doesn’t spend next year running for his life.

That’s one of the reasons why the old staff got fired. They relied too much on JUCOs on the offensive line. The one player who fit the profile of the kind of guy they should target, a South Carolina transfer starter, was their most valuable offensive lineman. Really, the only good one.

So Keeler knows what he has to do. Keep a solid chunk of the current roster and upgrade with the top end of the 6,000 or so players who won’t find a home. He already has shown the chops for being able to coach them up.

First, he has to get them to coach them and we’ll be keeping an eye on those developments over the next four or so weeks.

12.27.24
by

My Belated Christmas Wish List for Temple

Under this unfair system, the best Temple can hope for is to do what Toledo did on Thursday.

After hearing about 100 good things from new Temple head football coach K.C. Keeler, I’m hoping that two days after Christmas he’s a watch what I do, not watch what I say guy.

That’s it. That’s my entire realistic Christmas Wish List for Temple football.

(The unrealistic part is me winning tonight’s MegaMillions with the numbers 8-13-15-30-55 (6) and donating $100 million to Temple’s NIL football fund so Keeler can get any player he wants. That will only happen if I get struck by lightning and eaten by a shark while holding the ticket and hopefully handing it off to Arthur Johnson on Ocean City Beach.)

Our low/risk, high/reward, picks in college football. Toledo already came through.

The realistic part is watch what I do and not what I say when it comes to Keeler.

Why do I say that?

Heard something in the press conference from K.C. that really concerned me.

He said he wants to build a program with high school recruits.

Hmm.

Not a fan.

Hell, that’s what I would have done a decade ago at Temple.

That’s what Al Golden did. That’s what Matt Rhule did.

Unfortunately, those days are over.

Here’s what happens now if you recruit high school players:

One, you develop them.

If these numbers hit, K.C. Keeler can afford any player he wants at Temple. That’s my promise here.

Two, you lose them.

Developing means that you put them in a weight room for a year, redshirt them that year, play them as a redshirt freshman and–if they blossom–lose them to a Power 4 team by their sophomore year.

The reality in the G5 is that the only way to build a program that wins exciting bowl games (see Toledo’s win over Pitt yesterday) is to get them from the portal on the cheap.

Toledo didn’t beat Pitt with high school players or even JUCOs. Seventeen of the Rockets’ starters in a six-OT win over Pitt came from Power 4 schools where they were stuck as backups and only wanted a chance to show their stuff.

They gave a hometown discount (most were Ohio high school stars) for Toledo in the sense that they weren’t asking for big NIL money but just a chance to get on the field.

That’s the formula for Temple.

Temple cannot win a NIL bidding war with anyone. This is a hardscrabble school in a scrabble town whose grads had to look under beds and in the seams of couches for two tokens to get to school every day.

They don’t own Twitter or Tesla or even Tastykake. They’ve got no money.

That’s where the “watch what I do” part when it comes to Keeler comes in and not the “watch what I say” part. That’s because Keeler built his Sam Houston team not with high school players but great transfers from both FBS and FCS schools and that’s exactly what he has to do here. Because building a program on the backs of high school players is a bad idea at any level today.

Just wish he would have said so in the press conference.

12.22.24
by

Clayton Barnes: The Howie Roseman of Temple

When there are 8,000+ players in the portal and only 2,000 or so keep their scholarships, finding 20 or so gems among the other 6,000 is the job for a guy like Clayton Barnes.

Anyone hanging out at the Cherry and White street sign (see above) looking for the white smoke to come out of the top of the Edberg-Olson Complex chimney might be disappointed today.

When the smoke clears, it doesn’t look like Temple football will have its offensive coordinator today or tomorrow.

From what we hear, the Kirk Ciarrocca talks have fallen through because, while Temple paid former OC Danny Langsdorf a half-million dollars to continually throw 2-yard passes, that doesn’t come close to what the Temple grad currently is making at Rutgers.

Meanwhile, an addition that was made last week might be more important.

New head coach K.C. Keeler is bringing in Clayton Barnes to be his “general manager”–the so-called “Howie Roseman of Temple” and that’s been something we’ve been advocating for in this space for the last three years.

Because, while Temple will never be able to offer big-time NIL money, scouring the portal for disaffected P4 players good enough to start at that level but stuck as backup players to future NFL players might be the key to that success.

Barnes, like Roseman, has a keen eye for talent and has been primarily responsible for feeding Keeler the kind of talent that overachieves. Barnes is a Texas A&M graduate who was in charge of evaluating recruits and managing the football scholarships for the past two seasons under Keeler.

He did a pretty good job putting the roster together two years ago and a better job at keeping them together before this current season as Sam Houston State had only one player exit the portal before the opening game, the lowest among all of the 134 FBS teams.

Temple had no such guy under Stan Drayton, instead relying on the staff to evaluate newcomers and sticking with the old model of recruiting high school players and JUCOs.

That was the kind of thinking that led to three-straight 3-9 seasons.

Barnes concentrated on upgrading the Bearkats’ roster with a hefty dose of P4 recruits.

That led to an improvement from 3-9 to 9-3 this regular season and a bowl championship.

That involves not only scrutiny of a player’s football skills but also character.

The football transfer portal is a financial windfall for only the top one percent, who move to the SEC or the Big 10.

Most of the other players are looking for a chance to start and to increase their own football profile, either for the NFL or for a possible move up the latter down the line.

Even more of the players–the great majority–looking for riches and end up out on the street, their scholarships lost and their football careers over.

That’s a lesson worth teaching not only the current Temple football roster but 20 or so newcomers who could upgrade what the Owls have now.

The fact that they have a Czar of the portal probably means the roster will be upgraded for the first time in at least three years, maybe more.

Friday: My Christmas List for Temple Football

12.19.24
by

Keeler’s bowl presence mattered and here’s why

This is about as good a preview to what Temple’s offense and defense will look like in 2025.

Anyone who saw Sam Houston’s State’s 31-26 bowl win on Thursday night over Georgia Southern also saw that K.C. Keeler was in attendance when the ESPN2 broadcast cut away to him.

Not coaching but supporting his kids.

That matters to Temple for a couple of reasons.

One, and probably most importantly, Keeler probably was there to recruit a few key Sam Houston State players to Philadelphia.

There’s a quarterback, a running back and a few defensive backs that certainly could seriously upgrade the Owls although, in my humble opinion, Evan Simon–if he stays here–beats out any other quarterback for the job.

(Hell, he probably did the same under the old staff but they were too blind to see.)

Simon says (pun intended) that he loves Temple and I know we Temple fans love him. Keeler is too good of a football coach to see things any other way once the balls start flying in a few weeks at 10th and Diamond.

Two, Keeler’s presence at a SHS bowl game will show the Temple kids that he will care about them in the same way he cared about the Bearkats. Imagine this: Temple goes to a bowl game in two years and Keeler gets the Ohio State job. (Hey, if you think OSU won’t give the job to a 67-year-old UNC just hired a 72-year-old to replace a 73-year-old.) He won’t be working for Ohio State, but he will be there to support the Temple kids.

Sold his soul for $7.4 million and didn’t even support the Temple kids in the bowl game. Contrast that to Keeler and Temple has a gem.

That’s just the kind of guy Keeler showed that he was on Thursday night.

My feeling and this could be naive is that Keeler is too Philly a guy to leave even if a P4 program tries to lure him but we won’t know until we know.

Contrast that to this: Matt Rhule, in the same week he was preparing Temple for the AAC championship game, said there was no amount of money that could take him away from his Temple players.

Evidently, $7.4 million from Baylor was enough for Rhule to skip the Military Bowl where Temple was going for a school-record 11th win.

Instead, Rhule was out recruiting for Baylor and not supporting the Temple kids.

Now, Keeler was supporting the Sam Houston kids and, at the same time, probably recruiting for Temple.

At least we hope so.

In his first big character test as Temple coach, Keeler passed it with flying colors.

A little Orange and White but way more Cherry and White.

Monday: The Offensive Staff

12.16.24
by

TFF and Temple football: Back in business

Brian Smith’s loss was felt by every Rice fan, unlike Everett Withers’ loss at TU (felt by only one).

Every once in a while, you get an unexpected expense.

Today’s was $145.44 because a bad Acer adapter sucked all of the life out of my battery, putting the laptop out of commission.

I only found out because I went to write Monday’s regular post and no numbers or punctuation marks were showing and then the screen went black.

Brian Smith’s defense held Navy’s Blake Horvath to 10-for-21, 121 yards and two interceptions in a 24-10 win this year. Everett Withers’ defense held Horvath and company to 38 points.

Having zero technical skills, I took it to an expert and he figured it out.

New charger and new battery put us back in business.

So, too, can the same be said of Temple football.

Having zero football skills, both new President John Fry and old AD Arthur Johnson found an expert who already is showing signs of recharging the program.

Unlike the last time, they got a pro and not some apprentice learning from another pro.

This pro, K.C. Keeler, already is making an impact with the Owls by hiring defensive coordinator Brian Smith from the Rice Owls.

Go to the Rice message boards and there is much gnashing of teeth over Smith’s loss. Smith, unlike the last Temple defensive coordinator, Everett Withers, is a proven point-stopper. We only know one Temple fan who felt the loss of Withers, OwlsDaily editor Shawn Pastor, who called him “a great asset to the program.”

The “trade” of Brian Smith for Everett Withers could go down as the second-best football swap in Philadelphia this year (the Eagles letting D’Andre Swift go to the Bears and acquiring Saquon Barkley was probably the best).

Since Withers’ primary job was a DC, and since Withers gave up 39.7 ppgs per game as a DC at FIU in 2021 and 38.7 and 35.7 the last two years at Temple, I’ll pass on that so-called asset.

Basically, he got both Butch Davis and Stan Drayton fired. (Drayton probably deserved more blame than Davis because he hired Withers after the FIU disaster.)

“You had one job!”

Some asset.

Keeler went for the best guy available, not the best friend he felt more comfortable with and Smith has the numbers to back it up.

Smith’s defense finished ninth in the nation in passing defense, 36th in total defense and held opponents to just 25.4 points per game, more than 10 points per game lower than Withers’ best figure this decade. Smith, unlike Withers, was nominated for the Frank Broyles Award as best assistant coach in the nation.

Smith held a very good Navy offense to just 10 points in a 24-10 Rice victory and his 3-4 defense is particularly effective against triple-option teams like Army and Navy because it puts a nose guard over the A gap (to stop the fullback) and emphasizes speed from sideline to string out the option.

An additional benefit of that scheme is that it’s harder to recruit big interior linemen like defensive tackles and nose guards and easier to find linebackers and that’s probably why Keeler is going to keep what he did at Sam Houston State.

When your football team is broken, got to put it a bag and take to an expert and then plug it back in the AAC outlet.

So far, the additional expense of buying out Drayton and Keeler (at SHS) and paying Keeler on top of that portends that the Owls will be back in the business of winning sooner than later.

Friday: The Letter

12.12.24
by

The reviews are in and they are all good

The reviews are in on the new Temple head football coach and let’s just say they are a lot better than the reviews a certain McDonald’s in Altoona received this week.

Validation is always a good thing, and the Temple brass received plenty of it in the 10 or so days since hiring K.C. Keeler away from Sam Houston State.

That got me to thinking about the reaction to past Temple hires. I can’t remember a single time there was this much positive reaction to a Temple football head coaching hire since Wayne Hardin. Places like The New York Times raved about Temple hiring Hardin, who had Navy as the No. 2 team in the country in the 1962 season and won a pro championship later with the Philadelphia Bulldogs of the Continental League in 1966.

We all know what happened when Hardin decided to return to Philadelphia four years later.

Hardin became the winningest coach in Temple history, had four-straight winning seasons, won Temple’s first bowl game ever and was a mere 16 points from an unbeaten season in 1979 which would have almost assuredly gave Temple and Philadelphia a mythical national football championship.

In a way, Keeler decided to return to Philadelphia earlier this month and that’s a comparison that bodes well for Temple.

Keeler knows those bullet points all too well since his only disappointment in that 1979 season came at the hands of Temple. Keeler was a linebacker whose only loss in a 13-1 year was a 31-14 one to Hardin’s Temple team.

This is not a Temple fan. It is a WVU fan who was thrilled by the hiring of Rich Rodriguez.

That Delaware team didn’t have a “mythical” national championship then. It had a real one at the next level down from Temple and the national powers (now FCS).

Keeler, more than anyone else, knows how great Temple can be in this sport.

After hiring Keeler, Temple fans need to reflect on what they’ve seen over the last three years of the Stan Drayton Regime. Plenty of sub-level G5 talent, plus numerous games where the head-scratching moments came when Temple was either offsides, had false starts, illegal formations and linemen downfield.

Sam Houston fans never saw that kind of stuff and that’s why Temple hired K.C. Keeler nearly a dozen days ago.

Since then, Keeler has gotten to work revamping the coaching staff and making strides to do the same with the roster. Temple is the only team mentioned for a backup Ohio State linebacker who returned a pick six for a touchdown three months ago against Akron.

That’s the kind of player Temple needs. That’s the kind of player we’ve been preaching that Temple go after the last two years, guys who can play at the P4 level but are stuck behind other NFL players.

What did the previous staff do?

Go after JUCO players. The past staff was stuck in the 1980s, where the only way they knew how to fill immediate needs was to get JUCO players.

When you do that, you get JUCO results.

If you want to get big-time results, you’ve got to go after big-time players and Keeler understands that. Winning the portal means as much as winning the NFL draft and Keeler was so good at that a year ago that he lost only one player in the portal on the way to a 9-3 season.

There are plenty of big-time players in the portal, and plenty of guys who are looking for an opportunity to show themselves over a NIL payday. Temple needs to go after that type of hungry player and nobody more than Keeler understands that reality.

Others are noticing and that cannot be a bad thing and we haven’t had that happen in a half century.

Monday: The Letter