Ground Game: New pieces stand out

Hunter Smith’s high school recruiting film.

Recruiting guru Lou Adler is credited for saying it first:

“The best predictor of future performance is past performance.”

Adler said it in his capacity of recruiting business talent, but it also applies to football talent.

Last week, the Temple football Owls probably grabbed their starting quarterback in Gevani McCoy, although Evan Simon might have something to say about that.

Around the same time, the Owls appeared to have fixed their run game depth by adding Hunter Smith.

This is where the past performance comes into play.

With the addition of Smith, this is what Temple’s running back room looks like: Jay Ducker, the one-time leading rusher in the MAC is pairing with the one-time Louisiana-Monroe rushing leader in Smith.

Smith led the Warhawks with 507 rushing yards in 2023 before suffering an ACL injury. Ducker led the MAC in rushing two years earlier (2021) with 1,184 yards.

Temple head coach K.C. Keeler said Ducker had a “good camp” for the Owls in the spring but said Ducker needs to turn a lot of those yards he got into touchdowns and improve his closing speed. That opens the door for holdover Torrez Worthy to grab the job as he is the fastest back (4.49-40) since Ray Davis in the 2019 season. Davis now plays for the Buffalo Bills.

A red flag for both newcomers is that speed, as both scored just three touchdowns. Worthy outran the entire Tulane team for Temple’s only highlight in a 52-6 loss last year so if he wins the job, it will be by speed alone. A dark horse to win the job is another speedster, De’Carlos Young. Joquez Smith also had a 142-yard game for Temple two years ago so he’s in the mix as well.

At a number of positions, Keeler has brought in more significant transfer portal talent since Cherry and White Day than both Rod Carey and Stan Drayton did in the past six years.

The running back room is a perfect example of that.

Still, Worthy, Young (who hasn’t had a chance yet) and Joquez Smith have not produced the same kind of numbers at the FBS level as Ducker and Smith so the Owls appear to be in capable hands with those two.

At least past performance says so.

Friday: Getting a handle

Temple grabs a real quarterback in McCoy

Watching the NFL draft on Thursday night made me jealous.

Always a college football fan first and an NFL fan second, the last half-dozen or so years have soured me on college football and led me to realize the NFL has the best business model.

At least to capture the fans’ interest.

Temple’s new QB is in pretty good company.

Thursday night, the NFL proved why its business model is better than college football. Worst team gets the best pick in a league where there is a salary cap. The entire organization benefits with interest spread somewhat equally among 32 teams with the top teams sacrificing. Imagine how good the transfer portal would be if the 130th FBS team (Kent State) got the first choice and everybody had a salary cap? Never will happen but expect college football to lose a lot of fans under this new system that benefits only the top 1 percent.

If college football had basically the same thing and, say, NEXT Thursday was the first day of the transfer portal, Temple would have essentially a lottery pick with the 10th one.

Imagine the kind of excitement around here if the Owls were getting one of the best players in FBS college football, with his NIL money being paid by a pool of TV money where all of the other 129 FBS teams contribute.

Gevani McCoy started nine games for Oregon State last year.

Won’t ever happen because the NFL sees the big picture and the colleges want the top 1 percent to hoard the riches.

A week ago, Temple was excited to bring in the top quarterback in Division II football but he canceled his scheduled visit to North Broad in order to sign with Ole Miss.

Now the Owls have apparently replaced him with The Real McCoy.

Or at least one of them in Gevani McCoy, who won the Jerry Rice Award as the best freshman in FCS college football a couple of years ago.

His skill set fits both what new head coach K.C. Keeler and his offensive coordinator (Tyler Walker) want to do at Temple, which is to spread the field with receivers and, if nothing is open, have an elusive running threat at QB who can move the sticks on his own.

That doesn’t mean Evan Simon can’t beat him out because he certainly can.

What it does mean is that we won’t see what we saw too often over the last six years. Temple looked like a high school team when Anthony Russo missed games in the Rod Carey Era or E.J. Warner missed games in the Stan Drayton Era.

We spent all last offseason pleading with Drayton to get a big-time quarterback in here, but Drayton was more interested in taking a two-week summer vacation in Houston than finding the Owls someone to pull the trigger.

Keeler is rolling up his sleeves and getting the job done.

This is college football and quarterbacks are going to go down and miss games here and there and a good program has an insurance policy. Until yesterday, there was no insurance policy for Simon going down.

Now Simon becomes McCoy’s policy and McCoy becomes Simon’s and maybe, in McCoy, the Owls have someone who can be the best quarterback in the AAC.

Monday: The Ground Game

The flip side of the portal: Getting a P4 recruit

For a school like Temple, there are always two sides to the transfer portal.

One side, the bad one, is recruiting and developing talent for another team to steal.

The good side of this coin–often ignored–is that the transfer portal opens the Owls to acquire football talent they might not otherwise have a chance to get out of high school.

Take Cedar Creek’s Jo Jo Bermudez for instance. Temple has expressed an interest in him and he has expressed an interest in Temple.

It’s a trade that would benefit both since the Owls seem thin at wide receiver and Bermudez has a good chance of earning a starting job.

He set a South Jersey receiving record for yardage with 1,992 in his senior year of high school. His recruiting was down to the Big 10 (Rutgers) and the Big 12 (Cincinnati) and ultimately chose the Bearcats. While he didn’t play for the Bearcats, he transferred to Delaware and became their best wide receiver and caught a touchdown pass against Villanova in November.

Temple used to win recruiting battles with P4 schools but that was a long time ago and in a different era of college football. Al Golden’s first recruit was to beat out Boston College and Rutgers for the services of Kee-Ayre Griffin, who became both a starting running back and a starting quarterback for Golden. Matt Rhule beat out LSU and Rutgers for the services of Anthony Russo. Golden also stole Adrian Robinson from Pitt, among others.

Temple really hasn’t gotten that type of guy since Rhule left, although the transfer portal has sent players from Texas A&M, Florida, Penn State and other places to Temple. Most of them were backups who never made an impact at Temple but a player like Diwan Black was an exception last year.

Maybe Bermudez could fit into that category this year.

Now, if the Owls are able to land Bermudez, they would upgrade the talent in the room and competition only makes the team better.

Kajiya Hollawayne, Xavier Irvin and Tyler Stewart were running with the first team in the spring and that’s a little surprising because John Adams and Antonio Jones made the most big plays in actual games last year.

Right now, my starters are Adams and Jones at wide receiver and Ryder Kusch at tight end but with most teams playing three receivers, there is plenty of room for Bermudez to make an impact.

It’s the flip side of the transfer portal coin and could bring in a talent that the Owls would have had little chance of landing coming out of high school.

What most people don’t understand about college sports

After reading this, tell me where Temple gets the money to pay football or basketball players who are already getting scholarships worth almost $100,000?

The response never fails.

Every time I write something about the evils of the NIL and the transfer portal, I invariably get this response either on twitter, the comments below or facebook:

“These colleges make millions off the backs of the players. They deserve to be paid.”

Err, no.

The Ohio States and the Penn States make millions.

The Temples, the Kent States, the Georgia States, the Troys, the Sam Houstons, etc. don’t.

There are plenty more of the latter group than the former one.

Temple has to sell its ability to put players in the NFL and it has a strong history of that.

As many of 100 (or more) of the FBS schools LOSE money on football. Should those players be forced to pay back the schools who employ them?

No.

But to say these players deserve millions because universities makes millions is a misnomer because there is no bounty.

Look at Temple.

This week Temple president John Fry wrote a university-wide email (see above) about how Temple is strapped for cash and how the school is going to have to tighten that belt even more.

Temple isn’t the only school in that boat.

Ryder Kusch shows Reece Clark how playing tight end is done.

Maybe Memphis and Boise State make money on football.

I doubt that any other G5 schools do.

Temple did a lot of hard work recruiting a quarterback who was set to visit the school today. He canceled the visit and committed to Ole Miss on Tuesday. Temple lost a tight end (Reece Clark) today who entered the portal. Good for him. I don’t think he’s going to find any real money elsewhere. Let’s be real here. Clark is a nice player. He was outplayed in the spring by Ryder Kusch. Clark is a tweener. Not big enough to play tight end or fast enough to play wide receiver. He’s like a 6-3 forward in high school basketball. He didn’t light up the stat sheet for a 3-9 team. Doubt that any 9-3 teams are going to offer him money. He’s got to be realistic about his own ability. Instead, he’s probably listening to an agent.

He’s more likely to drop to FCS than continue to play at the highest level.

Better for Temple because head coach K.C. Keeler said that you are either all in or all out and Clark is all out. Now Keeler is building a team that is all in and that can only benefit Temple.

Although this number changes every day, there were only 1,452 FBS scholarships available as of 10 p.m. Thursday night. The math ain’t mathing for 90+ percent of these kids but don’t expect an “agent” to tell them that.

Ole Miss has money to pay football players.

Temple doesn’t.

Neither does almost every other G5 school yet a lot of G5 schools find a way to compete. One of those schools was Sam Houston, which won 9 games and a bowl game.

Its head coach?

K.C. Keeler.

It’s a lot tougher to win with players who are getting paid the old-fashioned way but there’s a lot to be said about building a culture where everyone is pretty much getting the same thing and there’s no locker room bickering why this one guy gets this and this other guy doesn’t get that.

Maybe that isn’t all of the Keeler winning formula, but it certainly is a big part of it.

Until some multi-billionaire Saudi horse racing aficionado wants to see what kind of havoc his disposable income can wreak on college football by backing Temple, spare me on the “kids deserve to get paid” angle.

Monday: An Intriguing Prospect

Cherry and White: Tough love and defense

K.C. Keeler tells the team if anyone enters the portal, he’s not taking them back. (Photo by Anthony Getz)

Defense and field goals dominated the 2025 Cherry and White game and one more thing.

Tough love.

Quarterback Tyler Douglas did nothing wrong on this pass but it ended up being a Pick 6.

First-year Temple head coach K.C. Keeler channeled his inner John Chaney when he made clear to any Owls considering the transfer portal he would not take them back. Keeler’s reasoning was sound. “Now that you have been with me, I told them if they go in the portal, we’re not taking them back,” he said.

The thinking there is this is the first time a lot of these Temple kids played for a Hall of Fame coach and they might be intrigued where he can lead them and the team.

Chaney did a similar thing long before the portal, telling anyone who transferred that they were not welcomed back. The famous quote was, “If you tell me you don’t love me, it’s over.”

It worked back then because Chaney had both the carrot and the stick.

We’ll see if it works now.

It was a bold move back then. It is even more today because there might be more money on the other side. Then again, there might not. More players who go into the portal find zero money and no scholarships on the other side than those who go in and expect to get rich.

Joe Greenwood (left) and College Hall of Fame running back Paul Palmer rock their letterwinner jackets.

For now, it’s a buyer’s market for the teams, not the players. Only the top 1 percent of the players in the portal get any real money and that’s from only the top 20 or so college football powerhouses.

So anyone who played on a 3-9 team would be wise to stay put and keep their scholarship.

As far as the game itself, the Owls went 5-for-5 in field goals but a point of emphasis will be to finish off those drives with touchdowns and not field goals. While Keeler praised newcomer Jay Ducker (21 carries for 66 yards), he also noted that Ducker needs to improve his finishing speed. If he doesn’t, Keeler has a nice insurance policy in Torrez Worthy, who is one of the fastest backs in the AAC. Worthy outran the whole Tulane team in the lone highlight of a 52-6 loss last year.

Keeler also said that Evan Simon “had a great spring” but that he’s “bringing in another quarterback” to compete for the starting job. My feeling here is that Simon is a good enough quarterback to produce a winning season at Temple but the fact that Temple doesn’t have another quarterback good enough to produce a winning season is the very reason Keeler should go after a similar level quarterback.

Defensively, Keeler said the line is “7-8 deep” and they should be able to stop people in this league given the personnel already here. Offensively, he said “iron sharpens iron” and how good the DL was all spring made the OL the most improved aspect of the team. Those of us who saw Simon running for his life last fall will have to see that to believe that against live competition. Still, it wouldn’t hurt to get a tackle who can protect Simon’s blindside.

Another reason they will hit the portal for a QB is his offensive staff is used to a running quarterback and nothing puts pressure on a modern defense than a quarterback who can move the sticks both running and passing.

Those are hard to come by and the competition for one should be furious. Sort of like it was on Saturday.

Friday: An intriguing prospect

A return to some coaching competency this spring

Take this from a guy who has been all but two of the last 40 or so Cherry and White games: This one as all the makings for being one of the best.

Trust me, the 2 p.m. kickoff for the Cherry and White should be one of the best. If not best, certainly among the most interesting.

I’ve been to the worst.

The worst was the “game” at Lincoln Financial Field in 2017 when 1,000 fans rattling around in a 70K stadium looked like a couple hundred.

A few years before that almost to the day I stood on the top bleacher at the Diamond Street end zone with an umbrella over my head and ducking behind the 6-foot-4 guy standing on the bleacher below me to get a view of Logan Marchi throwing two interceptions off his back foot. He was BY FAR … FAR … the worst of the four quarterbacks playing that day but somehow he started the opener at Notre Dame and was only able to put up 16 points in the next game against a team Rhode Island scorched for 20 points.

Weather forecast says “rain likely” but we are still six days away.

It sucked big time.

Anything will be better than those two games because for the first time since maybe Steve Addazio was here, there will be a lot of coaches who know what they were doing. (Not that Daz did but he brought with him the core staff of the 2010 Florida Gator squad and it was neat to see the professionalism with which they operated.)

Here are the five things I’m looking for:

Hope

You might say I’m a dreamer but, as the Beatles would say, I’m not the only one. New head coach K.C. Keeler did a lot with little at Rowan, Delaware and Sam Houston and his charge is to do the same at Temple.

Weather

Mid-April is always a crapshoot in Philadelphia. The forecast calls for rain but we are six days away and that can change.

Coaching

Last year, it was a clusterbleep because then head coach Stan Drayton stuck with a guy who gave up 38 ppg in his two prior stints as DC. Not surprising Everett Withers went out at Temple doing the same thing and cost his buddy a fourth season. Now there is a new defensive philosophy. Don’t sell that short because D.J. Eliot proved you could do more with the same players if they were coached differently. Brian Smith probably will prove the same thing. In the spring, they’ve been showing 5-2-4, 3-3-5 and 4-3-4 looks, which shows Smith is flexible.

Evan Simon is sacked by Temple in the 2022 Rutgers’ game

Position Battles

This might be the most important. We all know that Evan Simon No. 1 and Tyler Douglas is No. 2 at quarterback. Is the separation so wide at quarterback that Keeler brings a No. 2 from the portal or is Keeler so wedded to a running quarterback that he jumps over both and brings in a No. 1? Another battle to watch is the one between newcomer Jay Ducker (who started at both Memphis and Sam Houston) and Torrez Worthy, who might have been a 1,000-yard rusher at Temple last year if so-called “running back guru” Drayton didn’t dick around and start E.J. Wilson the first few games.

Special Teams

Both last year’s staff and this year’s staff say the second-best kicker in the AAC was Carl Hardin, who happened to be behind Maddox Trujillo. Yet Hardin MISSED two field goals in the last scrimmage (while also making two) and it’s hard to make a case he’s as reliable as Maddox was now. If he finishes up with a couple of makes and no misses, that’s going to put a lot of minds at ease. Also, does Temple continue with the rugby style punts?

Friday: Farewell to a Tradition

Monday: Takeaways from Cherry and White

Cherry and White: Another casualty of the madness

About the same time the best golfers in the world will be teeing up in Georgia for the penultimate round of that sport’s best tournament, two colors will be teeing it off at 10th and Diamond.

The Cherry and The White.

Jim Nance likes to call the former thing: “A Tradition Like Any Other.”

That’s why anyone mulling over whether or not they should attend this year should go.

The Masters will go on for many years to come.

The Cherry and White game will probably not.

Another casualty of the madness–and the sickness–that plagues college sports in general and college football in particular.

New Temple head coach K.C. Keeler floated the idea that this might be the last Cherry and White game ever and if he decides to end it, I agree with him.

What a great tradition, though.

Maybe golf fanatic Nance is right, but do you know a sports tradition that has–within the last 20 years or so–been played in at least six places and been part of a transition from bottom to (nearly) top as Temple football’s Cherry and White game?

I didn’t think so.

In the last 20 years, Temple’s Cherry and White football game has been played in 1) The Old Temple Stadium (2004), 2) Ambler (2006), 3) Cardinal O’Hara (2008), 4) Lincoln Financial Field (2010), 5) the soccer/field hockey complex (three times recently) and the 6) Edberg-Olson Football Complex (five times)?

Find me a moveable tradition like that and we can start the conversation about any other traditions.

It’s OK, too.

Accessible by train from anywhere in the Philly region

This year (April 12) the game will be played at the E-O. It’s also been played at Broad and Master, a $22 million “minor sports” site.

About 4-5,000 people will be attending the Cherry and White football festivities.

It’ll be different this year and in a bad way because of all the nostalgia.

Old-timers like me remember when it was a “real game” with tackling and a final score. Keeler has promised that much because “this is really important to Temple alumni that we play it as a game and we will.”

The last three years were glorified drills like hitting a running back with a tackling dummy. That sense of urgency carried over to the games in the fall.

Game used to be broadcast by Philly radio legends Bill Campbell and Steve Fredericks.

This time, the simulation will be real and it will be a welcome change because we’ve seen the very same process during Cherry and White Days presided over by successful coaches like Wayne Hardin, Bruce Arians, Al Golden and Matt Rhule. Whatever we watched the past three seasons did not work.

Hate, hate, hate to do this but our subscription prices for Getty Images and WordPress hosting have gone up and we need to cover that or entertain a pause on this blog until the fall. If you can’t contribute, no problem. If you can, we will know that we have the audience to continue

All of the prior Temple guys believed that the fall process included meaningful business in front of the fans on Cherry and White Day.

The fact that the new guy believes that, too, is a good sign for the fall and makes attendance by serious Owl fans mandatory.

This is a damn good tradition that will, sadly, come to an end until any sanity is restored to college football and that day is so far off I can confidently say I won’t be here to see it with you.

In between, though, we need to do what we have to do to get Temple football to the other side and, if ending the showcasing of our players for other teams to steal is over I’m all for it.

Monday: What’s Happening Here

Something positive: Keeler is holding it together

Last year, Stan Drayton allowed Rock, Paper and Scissors between Forrest Brock and Evan Simon to determine the first-team QB reps. Now Rock, Paper and Scissors doesn’t decide anything. Thanks to K.C. Keeler for that.

Let’s face it: College sports is a complete bleep show now.

More players entered the NCAA Division I basketball portal than ever on Thursday (we would give you the exact number but it was 1,700 at noon and 1,887 at 4 p.m. and probably over 2,000 now), including basically the entire Temple University men’s basketball team.

The Scotus decision on the NCAA vs. Alston in 2021 caused complete anarchy in college sports. The transfer portal preceded that but there was very little movement because there was no big money thrown around. Kids used the portal for the reason it was intended–to get playing time at another school when they weren’t getting it at their own.

Have to wonder if Whizzer White–an All-American football player in an era where amateurs dominated college sports–would have agreed with his colleagues if he had lived long enough to remain on the court.

Temple’s major sports have struggled since because the grads are not as deep-pocketed as the products of the SEC and Big 10 schools.

While coaches like Adam Fisher, Stan Drayton, Aaron McKie and Rod Carey haven’t been able to keep a semblance of sanity, probably the most impressive aspect of the first few months is that new head coach K.C. Keeler is holding things together. Make no mistake about it. Demerick Morris can play in the NFL. He is THAT good. He came to the correct conclusion that can be done for a championship coach. He dipped his toe into the water and went to Oklahoma State before deciding he made a mistake.

Maybe it was because of Keeler’s reputation. Maybe it was because of something else, like Keeler sitting down and having a heart-to-heart conversation with every single one of Temple’s scholarship players.

Still, what is unmistakable is Keeler is holding it together at Temple in a way Drayton, Carey and now Fisher haven’t demonstrated.

That’s an improvement in an era where chaos now reigns.

Less chaos probably means more wins for Temple.

Monday: What the awards tell you

Friday: The Last Cherry and White Game Ever?

Keeler’s first play call: Split the helmet baby

The greatest Temple helmet in history IMHO.

In the grand scheme of things, not one of the top 10 things K.C. Keeler needs to do as a head coach but it is certainly an important play call only he can make.

Go back to the “TEMPLE” helmet or keep the university signature “‘][‘ Logo.

Or do both.

The status quo is not an option.

There is a direct correlation between winning football at Temple and the TEMPLE helmet.

Had a long discussion with Matt Rhule about this a couple of days after he was hired and he said: “I don’t know if that’s my call.”

Told him that it was because the precedent had been established by a number of coaches before him.

Wayne Hardin changed an absolutely putrid-looking Owl logo to simply “TEMPLE” spelled out on the helmet.

“We want people to know who we are, that’s why I did it,” Hardin said at the time. “Plenty of teams have a logo or a T. We want to spell it out so there is no confusion.”

No consultancy fee necessary so splitting it in two is perfect.

TEMPLE had some–err, most–of its best football years wearing that helmet. It lasted from Hardin through Bruce Arians before Jerry Berndt switched it back to the T and 20 years of hell followed.

Like Rhule, though, Al Golden didn’t know if it was “his call” and stuck with the T through his first season, which was a 1-11 one.

After that season, though, Golden changed it and rubbing that helmet put some luck back in the program. Then Steve Addazio changed it back to the “T” and more hell followed after that.

“I did it because I associated that TEMPLE helmet with some of the toughest teams I played when I was at Penn State,” Golden said.

That’s why, when Rhule answered my first congratulatory email with “Mike, give me a call” I thought that was a good place to bring it up.

Rhule also stuck with the T, proving that the person inside the helmet was either just as or more important than the brand itself.

Since then, my King Solomon Solution has been my constant recommendation.

Split the baby.

Temple has had some bad helmets (and one good one) over the years.

“TEMPLE” on one side and the ‘][‘ on the other. The helmet was one of many things that didn’t make sense during the Stan Drayton Era because it had the ‘][” on one side and the number on the other. Talk about the Department of Redundancy Department.

The number was on both sides of the jerseys and didn’t need to be on a third spot.

Splitting the baby and putting the football logo on one side of the helmet and the university logo on the other would be the logical solution and it would be a bloodless one.

Somewhere up there, we think both Hardin and King Solomon would approve.

Friday: Some Progress

Next step: Some Temple football laughs

One of the best celebrations in recent Temple football history was this one in the lobby of The Liacouras Center when it was announced Temple would be returning to a bowl game for the first time in 30 years. That was fun.

When I was the sports editor of The Temple News and Wayne Hardin was well into his 13-year tenure as head coach, I asked him if he thought football should be fun.

“Good question, Mike,” he said. “I’ll tell you what I’ve always thought about that. The only fun in football is winning.”

The genesis of the question came from talking to so many guys who played under him who said his hard practices made the actual games fun because they were so prepared.

Thought about that the other day when, after the first “official” practice of the K.C. Keeler Era, the new Temple head coach said one of his early challenges was to get the guys to laugh.

Owls rejoice on the field after winning at UConn 17-14 in OT in 2012.

Pretty much said the team is too serious and noted the reasons for that was they were beat down by so many consecutive 3-9 seasons (three under Stan Drayton, one under Rod Carey).

Keeler didn’t have to say it but he is from the Wayne Hardin School of Football and probably believes the same things Wayne did. (After all, the only reason he ended up at Delaware instead of Temple when he played was because Hardin ran out of scholarships.)

The way to get these guys to loosen up and laugh is to win a few games and, if they have to be serious about it now, that can only bode well for the future.

Two College Football Hall of Fame coaches and the same philosophy about having fun.

Robby Anderson and Temple fans had smiles on their faces after beating Penn State in 2015.

Hard practices are followed by games in which the team knows exactly what they are supposed to do in critical situations.

Having fun is part of the deal.

Football, after all is a game, and in a game you are supposed to have fun.

When somebody keeps beating the crap out of you, it’s hard to enjoy anything.

Now the Owls are getting the hard work in this spring to determine a couple of things: One, who on the current roster is good enough to win now and, two, what are the holes the coaching staff needs to fill to help those guys achieve that.

Those coaches who were here last year wanted to fill holes but had no idea how. These ones do.

After years of gloom and doom post-game, it will be good to see the smiles on the faces of both Temple players and fans again.

If not this spring, then certainly this fall.

Monday: A Needed Change