Temple QBs in Practice: Between a Rock and (not so) Hard Place

K.C. Keeler and Tyler Walker discuss the quarterback competition.

Something Temple offensive coordinator Tyler Walker said about quarterbacks and getting them up to game speed stood out like a (not so) sore thumb.

Or leg.

Or shoulder.

Joey Schlaffer recreates on Thursday the exact same touchdown catch he had for Penn State a year ago in a 52-6 win over Villanova, a leaping one in the back of the end zone.

The Owls quarterbacks are not allowed to get hit in practice, anytime, anywhere.

Problematic any year, but particularly in a year that the Owls have two guys who’ve never–really seldom–have been hit in a real game.

“They’ve been getting better from the spring and the summer,” Walker said. “They put in a lot of reps. The one thing that I can’t recreate is the game reps. That goes without saying. We had a guy last year in Evan Simon who has 2,000 game reps. We just don’t have that. So there’s going to be some ups and downs. There’s going to be some trials.”

One of the highlights in Thursday’s practice was a 5-yard run for a touchdown by Ajani Sheppard. That would have been all the more impressive except for one thing.

The Temple defenders were not allowed to touch Sheppard on that 5-yard ruu.

Unfortunately, the Rhode Island defenders in Game One will not have that similar restriction.

The solution seems obvious. Make the quarterbacks live and take the orange jersey off but that’s not how college football works in 2026. It’s how college football worked in 1974 and 1979, but it hasn’t worked that way for a while.

Now Temple fans will have to find out if the Owls’ QBs can take a hit roughly about the same time the QBs themselves will find out if they can take a hit.

We’re exaggerating for effect here, but only a little.

According to ESPN.com, Jaxon Smolik–the Owls’ expected starter–played in only two games last year, Iowa and Nevada. In both games, he had no completions, no attempts, no carries.

Most importantly, he wasn’t touched.

Neither was Sheppard, who did not appear in a single game last year.

James Franklin on Jaxon Smolik.

Yikes indeed.

Now we can see why Walker was shaking his head when describing game reps.

The irony of all this is that the three highly regarded true freshmen coming in–Lamar Best, Brody Norman and Brady Palmer–have plenty of gameday hits under their belts a year ago.

It hasn’t helped them move up the depth chart yet, but don’t be surprised if the first group gets challenged by the second group sooner than later. Practice makes perfect, but there is a lot to be said about games themselves. That is the rock and hard place Temple finds themselves with respect to the quarterback position.

It’s a practice, not a game. How important is that?

Just ask Allen Iverson.

Monday: Speed To Burn

Keeler’s biggest coaching gamble: The QB position

James Franklin speaks highly of Jaxon Smolik in this video.

To hear K.C. Keeler tell it at American Conference Media Day, the Temple quarterback starting job is not settled law as practice starts in earnest this week.

In fact, it looks like a two-man battle between Cherry and White game star Jaxon Smolik and a guy who might fit offensive coordinator Tyler Walker’s scheme even better–Ajani Sheppard.

Both are long on talent and short on playing time and that’s why the quarterback position is Keeler’s biggest gamble at Temple, maybe in his entire coaching career. Last year, Keeler had two proven FBS starters to choose from in Evan Simon and Gevani McCoy.

This year he has none.

Well-paid staffs at Penn State, Rutgers and Washington State got a close-up look at the two current Temple options and decided, no, let’s not give either one an extended look in a real game.

That gives one pause.

As long as Jaxon is wearing a Cherry, and not White, helmet at Temple, he should put up big numbers. Those White helmets are bad luck.

Practice, yes. Not a game. You know what Allen Iverson thinks about that.

If it’s Smolik, and he gets the early nod it as it appears he will, he comes with endorsements.

It’s all a matter of trust at this point. Temple fans have to decide whether they trust Keeler and, in a way, Virginia Tech head coach James Franklin.

Franklin?

Yes.

A year ago, then head Penn State coach Franklin said he wasn’t “blowing smoke” or engaging in “coach talk” when he said that Smolik was looking good and that the PSU battle for the second spot behind Drew Allar would go on for an extended period of time.

If he was blowing smoke or engaging in coachspeak, Temple is in trouble.

There is some evidence that at one point Keeler thought that, too, as his first option was Saginaw State starting quarterback Mason McKenzie, who almost came here, but decided the lure of being a P4 starter was more enticing than playing for the winningest active head coach in college football. McKenzie would not have been a sure thing at Temple but he came with real game receipts that neither Smolik nor Sheppard have.

That forced Temple to Plan B and Smolik, who was Penn State’s Plan C. Or Sheppard, who was once the Plan B at both Washington State and Rutgers.

Now both are A and 1A at Temple and, like it or not, Keeler is faced with the task of beating a team in the second game of the season with that team’s third-team quarterback from last season.

Not ideal, but it wouldn’t be the first time Keeler has done more with less so this big gamble will be the most intriguing story line of the season.

Friday: Finally Getting His Due

Cherry and White: Singing a winning tune

K.C. Keeler donned a hat in the second half to after ditching one in the first. (Photos courtesy Zamani Feelings)

Fittingly on Cherry and White Day, a Temple grad hosted Saturday Night Live.

Colman Domingo.

Not much to takeaway from that coincidence other than the fact that Domingo was the fifth Temple graduate to host SNL (Bill Cosby, Tom Sizemore, Bob Saget and Quinta Brunson were the others).

That’s a lot of acting and comedy talent out of one place.

The same community that opposed building a campus stadium allowed this $17 million practice facility at 10th and Diamond to be approved. Just add 27,000 seats onto the 3,000 already there and away we go.

Probably a few of them have gone to Cherry and White games.

That’s always been a day where the football talent in the school was the main focus and it looked like Temple put enough talent on the field to make some noise in the American Conference.

Not the kind of noise that comes with comedy or acting, but certainly singing.

As in singing T for Temple U, which we haven’t heard enough of over the last seven-straight losing seasons.

No sweeter sound at the end of football games than hearing that and to hear it more often than not certainly is the goal this season.

We really won’t know for sure until September because the structure has changed so much in the last 50 years or so.

From Wayne Hardin’s “real games” that included kickoff returns with real tackling, and a score that gave declared a Cherry winner or a White winner, we have evolved to this:

Two things that might come in handy this year are practicing the kneel down at the end of the games (we didn’t see that) and the singing of “T for Temple U” which comes after wins (which we did).

Saturday’s “game” did not include a final score, and Avery Powell took the opening kickoff to the house except he didn’t. (Nobody was allowed to tackle the returner, and the whistle was blown once Powell got by everyone.) We predicted a 60-yard field goal by Carl Hardin and what we got instead was a 58-yarder that clanged off the left post. Close enough.

The 3,000 or so Temple fans who made the trip should consider themselves lucky. Not only did Temple have perfect weather (72 degrees and sunny), but it looked more like a “real game” than what we’ve seen more of the last seven years.

For one, former rivals Pitt and Rutgers didn’t even have games. For another, there was real tackling out there. Pitt and Rutgers are doing something a lot of schools have done but Temple has stayed the course and held the closest thing to a game without a score you can have. (I’m going to follow up to see how teams that didn’t hold spring games fared, record-wise, vs. those who did and we’ll post this at the end of the season.) For another, both Stan Drayton and Rod Carey avoided contact whenever possible.

There was plenty of contact on Saturday.

Head coach K.C. Keeler took the microphone and exactly 2 p.m. and said: “I want to welcome the greatest fans in the world. You are my people.”

Then the hitting began.

It’s always hard to tell the football end of things when the good guys are playing the good guys. When Jaxon Smolik throws a sidearm pass simultaneously 20 yards across his body and 40 yards downfield for a touchdown, it’s a great throw, sure, but then you worry about the defense.

When the defense shuts down the running game, you worry about the offensive line and on and on.

One thing we do know is that Smolik, Penn State’s third-string QB last year, looks like he has more ability than Ajani Sheppard, who has a backup at both Rutgers and Washington State yet that might have not been fair to Sheppard because quarterbacks weren’t allowed to show their open-field running ability.

K.C. Keeler tries out his SNL monologue, and it goes over well with the guys, including first-team All-American punter Dante Atton (7).

If I had to give an honest evaluation, Evan Simon looked much better in last year’s spring game than both Smolik and Sheppard and that’s a concern.

Keeler said summer practice basically begins on June 1 and I for one am hoping that true freshman Lamar Best balls out and makes the starting quarterback decision for Rhode Island a three-way dilemma. Put it this way: Had BYU named a starter after spring ball, Bear Bachmeier would not have had a chance to lead the Cougars to an 11-1 regular season. Like Best, he didn’t participate in spring ball. Like Bachmeier, Best has the “it” factor and is both dynamic and explosive. Can’t say I saw dynamic and explosive in either of the two quarterbacks on Saturday. Maybe consistent and steady are the best compliments I can muster at this point.

Other than that, the major takeaway is that the defensive line–the second area of concern–had a great spring and pressuring the quarterback will be improved over a year ago.

Does that mean more renditions of T for Temple U this year than last?

Who knows but judging from the way the current players sounded belting out a tune, maybe a SNL hosting gig is in one of their futures.

Friday: 5 Biggest Surprises from Spring Ball

5 Things We’d Like to See From Spring Ball

If the Owls beat Penn State this season, expect the drums to start beating for their own stadium like this one on the river

When you spend every March in Philadelphia, as I have (except for the few March months I covered the Phillies), there are certain signs of spring.

One, Rita’s Water Ice opens every March 1.

Two, there is a first sunset after 7 p.m. (Sunday).

Three, Temple starts spring football practice.

Can Phillies opening day be far behind? (Spoiler alert: It will be on us in a flash.)

Temple’s spring practice begins on Tuesday and ends with Cherry and White Day a month from now and we can tell you right now that the only significant outcome will be dibs on first- and second-team spots on the depth chart.

To say that you can determine what the Owls will do in the regular season based on that is really premature but there are some position battles that should be interesting.

Quarterback

Evan Simon set the bar high for the next QB.

We should see separation between Jaxon Smolik and Ajani Sheppard by Cherry and White Day. Expect one to quarterback the Cherry team and one to quarterback the White team. Right now, it’s a 50/50 shot who starts the opener against Rhode Island. Will it be that way in August? Something tells me one of the guys coming in during the summer, Lamar Best, balls out. If he does, it will be hard to keep that “it factor” off the field.

Pass rushers

Plenty of prospects to replace the reliable group of Cam’ron Stewart, Sultan Badmus, Khalil Poteat and Sekou Kromah but just as many suspects. To me, the key to winning in college football is keeping your quarterback’s jersey clean and getting the bad guy’s quarterback dirty and Temple did that in its most significant win, a 26-21 job over a UTSA team destroyed league champion Tulane, 48-26. Getting the guys who replicate that feat on a MORE consistent basis than that one game will be the difference between another 5-7 season and a 7-5 one.

Tight End

1,000 receiving yards and 15 touchdowns should be enough to get Peter Clarke drafted in the first round.

Temple has the best tight end in the country returning in Peter Clarke (IMHO) and he has a chance to become the next Owl drafted in the NFL’s first round. Still, as good as Clarke is, he wasn’t the starter in the opening game last season (spring sensation Ryder Kusch was). Does Temple go two tight ends to jumpstart the running game? That’s an option for the Owls to work on this spring.

Kick returner

Temple had one of the best punt returners in the country in JoJo Bermudez last season. Question is do you use your best wide receiver on punt returns again or find someone else? I think redshirt freshman Tylik Mitchell is one of the many who can fit that role. He ran a 10.7, 100 meters in high school. How fast is that? Former Temple superstar running back Bernard Pierce WON the PIAA state indoor 100 meters as a high school senior at Glen Mills with a 10.8. Mitchell was an elusive running back in North Carolina, so he’s got the same “twitch” to his return game that Bermudez has.

Secondary

The Owls have always had transfers come in to take up key spots and this year is no exception. Purdue transfer Earl Culp should be able to compete for a starting spot as should Asa Locks. There’s always room for a wild card to impress.

Friday: Second Seasons

Monday: Under Attack

Lamar Best’s chances to start just skyrocketed

Lamar Best’s high school film is clearly superior to the high school film of Smolik and Sheppard.

Back when Tiger Woods was winning just about every major golf tournament that there was, sports books had a standard bet before majors: Woods against the field.

Jaxon Smolik played third string QB at Penn State but an interesting tidbit is that he played QB at Dowling Catholic in Iowa which is the high school that produced Caitlin Clark.

Woods won just enough to make the bet–appealing on its face–a moneymaker for the house.

K.C. Keeler went into Temple’s offseason promising to get an experienced QB or two and some Owl fans, me included, weren’t expecting a Woods but certainly hoping for someone who reached the leaderboard of some quarterback competition on the field somewhere.

Instead, they got a couple of guys–third stringers at Penn State and Washington State–who now have a 50/50 chance to win the starting job at some point before the Sept. 5 opener.

Or at least a significant shot against a field that includes three true freshmen.

Say, those three–Brody Norman, Brady Palmer and Lamar Best–are roughly the field and the two transfer portal acquisitions, Ajani Sheppard and Jaxon Smolik–are “Tiger Woods.”

I’ll take the field, specifically Temple’s “secret weapon” in Best, whose film is off the charts. Best is every bit the passer P.J. Walker was and a far better runner. All Walker did was break every career passing mark at Temple.

Ajani Sheppard was third string at Rutgers behind Gavin Wimsatt and Evan Simon.

He might not be the starter but Temple’s failure to get a high achieving starter in its two transfer portal acquisitions raises significant concerns.

Among them, this: Smolik got on the field in a real game and did virtually nothing for Penn State. Same with Sheppard in stints and Rutgers and Washington State.

When you have a chance to get on the field in an actual game, you’ve got to do something. Neither of them did. Sheppard, like former Temple quarterback Evan Simon, is a one-time Rutgers’ backup but Simon threw for over 300 yards in a Big 10 game at Iowa so you knew he came with receipts.

Neither of these guys are coming with receipts.

Both, like Best, Norman, and Palmer, have good high school film but at least in the two transfer portal cases, that film has not translated into actual results in real college football games.

Maybe they will at Temple and maybe they won’t, but they haven’t so far, and the best predictor of future success is past success. I was hoping Temple would land the Saginaw Valley or Western Carolina quarterbacks, but apparently the staff whiffed on those two high-achievers.

This seems like settling to me and far from the dynamic duo of Simon and Gevani McCoy, but we will see.

Back to the drawing board.

BYU’s Bear Bachmeier showed a “true freshman” can go 11-1 on a college football field so that’s why I’m taking the freshman field against the two transfer portal pickups. He had to come from a long way in summer camp to beat more experienced quarterbacks who had a full spring and maybe that’s what will happen here.

May the Best man win.

Or at least the most talented one.

Friday: Best Available